Mrs. K’s Language Arts Blog

“There is a crack in everything. That’s how the light gets in.” ~Leonard Cohen

Want Feedback?

We could all benefit from a little feedbackiz0460151.jpg on our works-in-progress.  If you would like honest reactions to your work and suggestions for revision from the Creative Writing class or from Imagery members, paste your original piece in the comment box and see what develops.

Writers, let us know what bothers you in the piece. Problems? What specific passages would you like us to consider?

Responders,  point out memorable wording, phrases, passages and ask specific questions. If the piece were yours, what would you do to strengthen it?  Remember, be thoughtful and honest.

15 Responses to “Want Feedback?”

  1. Paige H Says:

    These hands

    These hands that I see everyday,
    Make me happy when I’m sad,
    And comfort me when I need it.
    When I see these hands,
    They are large…
    My fists are always engulfed by them.
    Roughly tender…
    As cliché as it seems…
    They’re full of love,
    And full of hate.

    Cut, bruised, scarred,
    The memories of the past
    Are never easily forgotten.
    I can feel those hands
    Run through my hair,
    And carry me
    When I can’t walk.

    These hands that I see
    Are aged,
    Indeed,
    But young,
    Never the less
    In the heart
    Of their beholder.

    Darken skin,
    With blue veins to see…
    They’ve been here with me
    All the way.
    In sickness
    And
    In health…

    Even in past memories
    I can see…
    Those hands that hold mine gently,
    That teach me how to be myself…
    The hands that protect me,
    And are afraid to let me go…
    Even now.

    These hands…
    Will be with me,
    Even when they wither away.
    When I stumble,
    And when I fall
    And when I walk the isle…

    Those hands that love me kind,
    And love me tenderly,
    Will always be there next to me.
    Even when I feel they’re gone.
    Those bone worked hands…
    Those callused hands…
    Those roughly gentle hands…
    The hands of my father.

  2. Haley S. Says:

    For Paige Ha: This reminds me of my grandfather, a lot. It made me tear up. The part, “They are large… My fists are always engulfed by them.” is my favorite.

  3. Haley S. Says:

    Pure

    You’re sitting on a
    fluffy
    white
    cloud
    near the most
    beautiful
    island you have ever seen.
    Air
    thick with humidity
    seeps into your taste buds,
    sugary like
    ice
    cream
    but warm.
    Smell the nights rain,
    hear the wind through the trees,
    feel the silk on your skin.
    You are in
    serenity.

    *I’m not sure about the title.

  4. Dylan C Says:

    For Paige Ha: I thought the poem was amazing. When you read it out loud in class, you made me feel the bond between you and your father. You told such a strong story and let the class feel how much your father meant to you. It is truly a deep hearted work of art and I think your father will appreciate it.

  5. Kyle C Says:

    Returning to the Garden

    My grove of serenity…
    The white flowers shine
    Through the darkness of my wayward heart
    A lone tree stands,
    The perfect metaphor
    Crumbled twigs and shattered leaves
    Closely mirror shattered dreams
    But offer comfort
    In knowing that in death,
    They are still together
    Released from pain and panic
    No longer corrupted by the Vice of Man,
    Embraced by the Virtues of the universe
    The ethereal energy of all being
    Cries wordlessly
    Through this forest of tranquility
    And the mighty oak,
    The deepest skies
    They could never make me feel small,
    Not when the world’s injustice
    Requires, of all of us, a mighty hero
    Someone to quench
    The flames of crimson hatred
    Someone to rust the blade of War
    Someone to lead us
    To pools of enlightenment,
    Someone to exalt humanity
    To its highest plateau
    In this world of darkness and bigotry,
    There is no time for ineptitude
    There is, in all the disharmony of the modern world,
    No room for doubt
    No room for fear
    And as I stand in my peaceful grove,
    The winds call my name
    They whisper all the secrets of the universe
    And I euphorically whisper back,
    Praising the Goddess
    For the blessings of this life
    And I know, when my time has come to die,
    When I have spent my life fighting,
    When I have given everything besides given up,
    I will be content in knowing
    That in the end,
    I will return to the peace of the Garden.

  6. Kyle C Says:

    For Paige Ha: I really enjoyed your poem. I think the duality of your poem in describing your father’s hands as full of love as well as hate was very creative. Showing the beauty of your father despite the imperfections is a classic and admirable theme. Very nice work :)

    For Haley: Very good imagery. I could taste clouds on my tongue, sugary and airy, and very relaxed. Nice job. (Good title though. I don’t see much need for change, though if you did, maybe something like ‘Bliss’?)

  7. Adam E Says:

    Paige H’s poem painted a bright picture into my head of the relationship between her and her father. I could just tell how close they are together. Sometimes we forget the simple things in life that really matter and I just wanna say thanks to Paige for making me realize that right now.

  8. Kyle C Says:

    If Only…

    What if
    There was a world in which
    Hatred reigned supreme?
    Where bigotry was the standard
    And brotherhood was the exception?
    Where oppression claimed the hearts
    Of everyone it touched?

    What if
    There was a world in which
    Progress was slowed by collective falsities?
    Where discovery was blatantly halted
    And ideas were restrained?
    Where we were too afraid to accept the idea
    That everyone is beautiful?

    What if
    There was a world in which
    Human compassion was a myth?
    Where love and peace were considered archaic
    And violence was an honored tradition?
    Where Hatred,
    Anger
    Violence
    Disdain
    Crime
    Repression
    Corruption
    Apathy
    Sorrow
    Fear
    Ruled the lives of everyone?

    The truth is…from where we’re headed,
    That world doesn’t look too fictitious
    Our paths lead down a frightening road
    And we perpetuate the vicious cycle
    By passing down evil doctrines
    Down to the next generation
    But let me ask another question…

    What if
    There was a world in which
    We lived out the dream of all humanity?
    Living in perfect serenity,
    No war
    No hate
    No violence
    Discovering the mysteries of this Beautiful world
    Together, hand in hand, as brethren

    What if
    There was a world in which
    There was nothing left to fight for?
    We immediately gave
    Our trust
    Compassion
    Freedom
    And the freest form of love
    Without having to fight for it?
    Without struggle?
    Embracing the unending beauty of the Universe
    Without any form of conflict…
    The truth is
    I’d be kind of bored.
    But that’s a risk I’m willing to take.

    What if
    Every day was sensation?
    If we embraced the endless beauty Surrounding us
    The universe,
    Our precious world,
    And most importantly, each other
    Surrounding ourselves
    With the truest beauty of love
    And our Mother God
    Then we could truly bring
    Heaven to Earth
    Make this life a glistening Paradise…
    Oh, if only…

  9. Paige Ha Says:

    Kyle C’s poem(s): Kyle you always write these wonderful poems, but…I feel as if I can’t really understand them with all the fancy word play. I’ll admit…sometimes I don’t know what you’re talking about in your poems.

  10. Mary G. Says:

    for Haley S.

    I like the idea of this poem. My favorite part was,
    “Air
    thick with humidity
    seeps into your taste buds.”

    If this was my poem, the only thing I would change is my description of the clouds because ‘fluffy’ is a little cliche and overused.

    What is so beautiful about the island that it makes you feel serene?

    For condensing: Do you need ‘you are in’ before the word serenity?

    Again, very nice poem.

  11. Mary G. Says:

    Fireflies interweave
    Between red embers
    Left to right
    Right to left
    In a desperate chase
    To reach their
    Destination first
    While glazed
    Unseeing
    Luminous eyes
    Bedecked with
    Golden-rod beads
    Pass indifferently
    Trudging along
    On their own
    Concrete path

    *I really need a title for this*

  12. Brittany W Says:

    Haley:

    I really like it actually.
    I really get a sense of it. If it were mine, I’d do a little more with “You are in serenity.” It seems a little bland compared to the rest of the poem.
    But I really like it other than that.
    =D

  13. Kyle C Says:

    For Mary G: Your poem was pretty good. I liked the rhythym of imagining the so-called ‘fireflies’ dancing. Also, words like ‘interweaved’ and phrases like ‘bedecked with goldenrod beads’ paint a nice picture. I’m not 100% sure if you need the ‘unseeing’ part when describing the ‘eyes’, but I can see where you’re going with it. Maybe you could take it a little further? As for the title, my first thought is something like ‘Wayfarer’ to help with the idea of traveling, but you could also play with the metaphor of the fireflies and some variation of that. Experiment and have fun! Good work, though.

  14. Kyle C Says:

    The Negative Realms of Being (Death)

    Where is the dream I once called reality?
    Dangled before my eyes, like a pendulum
    Tick, tick, tick
    This realm of darkness
    Has no birds; there are no blue skies
    Only the darkest sky below, around, and within
    Working its magic within a new domain
    Consumes me, though it has no mouth
    Burns me, though there is no warmth
    Oblivion calls my name wordlessly with disdain
    This scornful darkness annihilates my body
    Strikes relentlessly with its contempt for life
    Creating paradoxical disbelief
    Caressing me with the silken kiss of breathless air
    Singing the disharmony of its spite, and sounds so surreal
    Unlike the night of reality…
    Ah, to remember! The crispness of the air!
    The moon, the stars…
    This night has no stars, no moon
    Entering through my mouth,
    Leaves the taste of cruelty on my tongue
    Yet I can taste it only in memory…
    I only have the dream of a body…
    I only have a vision of what life was like
    In the splendor of its vastness
    Is this darkness a nightmare I cannot see?
    With no heart, I agonize
    With no body, I struggle
    With no eyes, I cry cold tears
    With no mouth, I argue
    Struggle as I may to see the world again,
    My actions are vain
    For the words have as much a sound
    As these tears have warmth upon my cheek
    For I know I can never be released from this pain
    Not even in the solitude of Death…

  15. Kyle C Says:

    To Love One’s Self

    In my struggle with myself,
    There is no poetry
    In my quest to understand,
    There is vanity
    In my ordeal of decadence,
    There is no beauty.
    In my search for transcendence,
    There is mockery

    This countenance I bear,
    This visage that I wear,
    Hides helplessness beyond repair
    A parody of man,
    Claiming greater pain
    Where I grant the world my love,
    I give myself disdain

    Why, then, do I seek glory,
    If man would soon forget?
    For what cause am I exalted,
    If they never comprehend?
    Can wings grant me ascension
    If their plumes will burn to ash?
    Where revelation beckons me
    Will I have the power to oblige?

    This countenance I bear,
    This visage that I wear,
    Is but a mask that cloaks despair
    A parody of man,
    Claiming greater pain
    Where I grant the world my love,
    I give myself disdain

    I will never be a sainted hero,
    For a darkness fills my veins:
    The perversion of my vanity,
    The filth of its refrain

    The causes of my servitude
    Are traced to my ineptitude
    Leaving me ashamed
    Ambition deep inside of me
    Will yield inside to vanity
    Leaves myself to blame…

    This world demands a hero,
    To cast away its chains
    A champion of rectitude
    Who cannot be restrained

    This countenance I bear,
    This visage that I wear
    A pale façade beyond compare
    A parody of man
    Claiming greater pain
    Where I grant the world my love,
    I give myself disdain

    This world, it lacks a hero
    While cities writhe in flames
    Somehow, I hear it calling,
    The message it contains:

    “You can’t afford your servitude
    No room left for ineptitude
    You have no other choice
    Cast away insanity
    Be freed from what was vanity
    In redemption, now, rejoice!”

    This doubtfulness impaired,
    My fortitude repaired,
    Released from dark in which I was ensnared
    Where hate will pressure onwards,
    I will make its efforts vain
    I have learnt to love myself
    And rise above my pain

    I know I am the hero,
    Who shall cast away the chains
    The one to ride on wings of dreams
    And free humanity of pain

    I shall raze those left to servitude,
    And shatter all ineptitude
    I will cry my heart’s refrain:
    This love that burns inside of me
    Stretches on for all infinity
    I am bereft of my disdain

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>