Greatest films are not the same as best films. I’d feel very “creepy” if I said some of these are my favorites–some of them do not paint a very bright picture of humanity. But, I think that all of them are made without flaws. Yes, some of them are older than I am and some are even in black and white. Greatest = Masterpiece.
In no particular order–
1. Citizen Kane–I believe that this is the greatest film of all time. It was made by Orson Welles, and it was well ahead of its time. The storyline, the camera angles, the acting, the set designs–are all worth third and fourth looks.
2. Once Upon a Time in the West—I think this film is the greatest western of all time. It does require some patience. Henry Fonda plays the “baddest bad guy” you’ll ever see in a film And he played Tom Joad in The Grapes of Wrath and Norman Thayer in On Golden Pond. Sergio Leone created the “Spaghetti Western” and this is THE ONE. The close-ups, the music used to identify individual characters, the editing, the sound—wow, wow, wow.
3. Mystic River–I believe that this film is perfect. However, it is very uncomfortable to watch. Clint Eastwood gets better with age. He assembled a great cast with Sean Penn, Tim Robbins, Kevin Bacon, Laurence Fishburne, Laura Linney, Marcia Gay Harden, and others–and he wastes no shots in this film either. The music is his too. But, as I said, it’s tough to watch.
4. The Natural–the greatest sports film of all time. Okay, throw out reality; throw in mythology and fantasy. This film contains the greatest home run you will ever see in a film. And, like most great sports films, it’s a story about redemption. And Robert Redford can play baseball.
5. Psycho– make sure it’s the 1960 Alfred Hitchcock version–black and white. No one made suspense films like Hitchcock. This movie should be in black and white. Hitchcock made it that way on purpose. Watch the shadows and camera angles in this one. Uh, the censors almost did not allow the shot of the toilet flushing. Movies have come a long way, true? Watch this one with the lights on. Bernard Herrmann uses only strings in the music score. Wow, wow, wow.